Billy Crystal is a nine-time Oscar host and a revered comedy legend. Josh Gad is an up-and-coming comedy star who was a voice in the biggest animated movie of all time. So what happens when these two are forced to work together?
The Comedians is a comedy mockumentary about the behind-the-scenes making of the fictional The Billy and Josh Show, where the two stars play fictionalized versions of themselves. The conflict between stars Billy Crystal (SNL fame) and Josh Gad (Olaf from Frozen) is central. After FX decides that Billy’s planned television show needs to be spruced up, they pair him with Frozen star Josh Gad. What ultimately results is two comedians whose comedy styles don’t mesh, as they pretend to be friendly while backstabbing each other to get what they want.
This is a series I came across one day as I was randomly scrolling through Hulu. The show only ran for one season, with a total of thirteen episodes, which is incredibly disappointing. The Comedians deserved far more than it got, because it is so well done. It consistently delivers big laughs, while also having a lot of heart to it.
I have a soft spot for television series that follow comedians playing themselves. Curb Your Enthusiasm, Maron, Legit, Louie before everything came out about Louis C.K. — these shows all feature comedians playing an exaggerated, a**hole version of themselves. While one may argue that The Comedians is simply following the trend of the aforementioned series, Billy Crystal and Josh Gad both play the part perfectly.
When we meet Billy Crystal in The Comedians, he’s been a comedy legend for decades. He’s had a massive career, but now he’s trying to get back out there in the public consciousness. While Billy ultimately feels insecure about his standing, this is masked when he is introduced to Josh Gad. Josh may be rising up the ranks in comedy, but Billy doesn’t understand Josh’s humor and has very little respect for him. Billy uses this to feel better about himself.